Preview

MGIMO Review of International Relations

Advanced search

The Fate of General Radko Dimitriev and His Memory in Context of Russian-Bulgarian Relations of the Late 19th – Early 20th centuries

https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2019-6-69-7-27

Abstract

This article examines the biography of the Bulgarian-born General Radko Dimitriev (1859–1918), who was convinced that the good of his homeland was inextricably linked with Russia and depended on good relations with it. For this good, he went to the overthrow of the monarch, but a decade later due to changes in the vector of Bulgarian policy was able to return home and become a hero. In 1913–1914, R. Dimitriev served as Bulgaria's envoy to Russia and tried to change the negative image of his country. With the outbreak of World War I, he joined the Russian army, and a year later in Bulgaria he was declared a deserter and a traitor. In 1918 he was executed by the Bolsheviks in Pyatigorsk, and in a few decades he became practically a symbol of friendship between the Bulgarian and Russian peoples, which led to retouching the circumstances of his death. The article traces the actions of the General and his motivation. Despite his Bulgarian origin, in 1914 he became nearly the main hero of the war in the Russian public space. The reasons for its popularity were not only in the im-portance of his victories, but also in the fact that R. Dimitriev was called the incarnation of A. V. Suvorov and M. D. Skobelev. The article shows what values, embodiments of which were these popular warlords, were characteristic this Bulgarian general. This is a personal part in the fighting, the care of soldiers, democracy in communication. Modern Russian military also has moved to a new paradigm of command, which, however, worked against their popularity among the soldiers. And at the same time, values of the commander of Suvorov's or Skobelev's types were insolvent in the conditions of revolutionary commotion, and R. Dimitriev lost control of the parts entrusted to it. Because of their gener-osity and love for Russia, he refused to take part in the Civil war that decided his death.

The author declares absence of conflict of interest.

About the Author

N. S. Gusev
Institute of Slavic Studies RAS
Russian Federation

Nikita S. Gusev – Candidate of Historical Sciences, Senior Researcher 

119991, Moscow, Leninsky prospect, 32-A



References

1. Nekludoff A. 1920. Diplomatic Reminiscences before and during World War, 1911–1917. London: John Murray. 541 p.

2. Azmanov D. 1999. General Radko Dimitriev. Voennoistoricheski sbornik. №4.Р. 50-73 (In Bulgarian)

3. Airapetov O.R. 2014. Uchastie Rossiiskoi imperii v Pervoi mirovoi voine (1914–1917). Tom 2: 1915 god – apogee [Participation of the Russian Empire in the First World war (1914-1917). Vol. 2: 1915 – apogee]. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole. 624 p. (In Russian)

4. Airapetov O.R. 2015. Uchastie Rossiiskoi imperii v Pervoi mirovoi voine (1914–1917): 1916 god. Sverkhnapriazhenie [Participation of the Russian Empire in the First world war (1914-1917): 1916. Over-voltage]. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole. 384 p. (In Russian)

5. Belii Iu. 2001. Radko Dimitriev, b"lgarski general na ruska sluzhba, i negovata tragediia [Bulgarian General of the Russian Service, and his Tragedy]. Istoricheski pregled. №5-6. p. 188-196. (In Bulgarian)

6. Bolgarin s dushoiu Skobeleva. Doblestnyi geroi, general Radko Dimitriev i drugie [Bulgarian with the Soul of Skobelev. Valiant Hero, General Radko Dmitriev and Other]. 1914. Moscow: Tipografiia P.V. Bel'tsova. 16 p. (In Russian)

7. Bondarenko V. 2016. Russkii nekropol' na Shipke [Russian Necropolis at the Shipka]. Moscow: OOO «Staraia Basmannaia». 688 p. (In Russian)

8. Bonch-Bruevich M.D. 1957. Vsia vlast' Sovetam. Vospominaniia [All power to the Soviets. Memory lane]. Moscow: Voennoe izdatel'stvo. 358 p. (In Russian)

9. Brusilov A.A. 2013. Moi vospominaniia [My Memories]. Moscow: Veche. 308 p. (In Russian)

10. Budennyi S.M. 1958. Proidennyi put'. Kniga pervaia [The Passed Way. Book 1]. Moscow: Voenizdat. 448 p. (In Russian)

11. Chakalov S. 2013. Zapiski bolgarskogo kadeta (1911–1921 gody) [Notes of Bulgarian Cadet (1911–1921)]. In Beloemigranty v Bolgarii. Vospominaniia. Ed. by V.V. Chumachenko etc. Moscow: Novye pechatnye tekhnologii; Sinerzhi. 794 p. (In Russian)

12. Cherepanov A.I. 1984. Pole ratnoe moe [My Battlefield]. Moscow: Voenizdat. 304 p. (In Russian)

13. Geroi nastoiashchei Velikoi voiny Radko-Dimitriev. S portretom i sobstvennoruchnoi podpis'iu [The Hero of this Great War Radko-Dimitriev. With a Portrait and a Handwritten Signature]. 1914. Petrograd: Tipografiia P. Usova. 9 p. (In Russian)

14. Gusev N.S. 2014. Bolgarskoe voennoe rukovodstvo v otsenkakh russkikh zhurnalis-tov v period Balkanskikh voin [Bulgarian Military Leadership in the Assess-ments of Russian Journalists during the Balkan Wars]. Rossiisko-bolgarskie nauchnye diskussii. Rossiiskaia i bolgarskaia gosudarstvennost': problemy vzaimodeistviia. XIX–XXI vv. Ed. by V.P. Kozlov. Moscow: ISl RAN. 347 p. P. 125-140. (In Russian)

15. Gusev N.S. 2014. Russkie i bolgary posle Balkanskikh voin: vzaimnoe razocharovanie [Russians and Bulgarians after the Balkan Wars: Mutual Disap-pointment]. Slavianskii al'manakh. Vol. 1-2. P. 123-133. (In Russian) URL: https://www.academia.edu/11034354/Русские_и_болгары_после_Балканских_войн_взаимное_разочарование_Славянский_альманах_2014._Вып._1-2_._М._2014 (accessed 23.09.2019)

16. Gusev N.S. 2017. Patriarkh otechestvennoi voennoi zhurnalistiki Vas. I. NemirovichDanchenko i ego korrespondentsiia s Pervoi balkanskoi voiny [Patriarch of Russian Military Journalism Vas. I. Nemirovich-Danchenko and his Correspondence from the First Balkan War].

17. Studia historiae Bulgariae et Europae Orientalis. K iubileiu T. V. Volokitinoi. Ed. by E.L. Valeva etc. Moscow: Institut slavianovedeniia. 440 p. P. 31-44. (In Russian)

18. Gusev N.S. 2018. Razgon manifestatsii v podderzhku slavian v Rossii vesnoi 1913 goda [Dispersal of Demonstrations in Support of the Slavs in Russia in the Spring of 1913]. Slavianovedenie. №3. P. 3-14. (In Russian)

19. Gusev N.S. 2019. Shtrikhi k dorevoliutsionnoi biografii akademika N.S. Derzhavina [The Finishing Touches to the Pre-Revolutionary Biography of Academician N.S. Derzhavin]. Arkhivnyi poisk. Vypusk 1: elektronnyi sbornik nauchnykh statei i publikatsii. Ed. by D.V. Anosov etc. Moscow: Arkhiv RAN. 532 p. P. 55-67. (In Russian)

20. Dimitriev R. 1922. Treta armiia v Balkanskata voina 1912 godina [Third Army in the Balkan War of 1912]. Sofia: Armeiskiia Voenno-izdatelski Fond. 320 p. (In Bulgarian)

21. Drenski I. 1962. General Radko Dimitriev. Biografichen ocherk [General Radko Dimitriev. Biographical Sketch]. Sofia: D"rzhavno voenno izdatelstvo. 198 p. (In Bulgarian)

22. Enchevich M.D. 2004. Izpoved na edin rodoliubets [Recognition of a Patriot]. Sofia: Faktum. 221 p. (In Bulgarian)

23. Ianchev V. 2006. Armiia, obshchestven red i v"treshnata sigurnost. B"lgarskiia opit. 1878–1912 [Army, Public Order and Internal Security. Bulgarian Experience. 1878–1912]. Sofia: IF94. 308 p. (In Bulgarian)

24. Ivanov A.A., Repnikov A.V. 2014. «Bolgarskaia izmena»: russkie pravye o vstuplenii Bolgarii v Pervuiu mirovuiu voinu na storone Tsentral'nykh derzhav [“Bulgarian’s Treason”: Russian Right Politics about Bulgaria’s Entry into the First World War on the Side of the Central States]. Noveishaia istoriia Rossii. 3(11). P. 197-217. (In Russian)

25. Ilchev I. 1990. B"lgariia i Antantata prez P"rvata svetovna voina [Bulgaria and the Entente during the First World War]. Sofiia: Nauka i izkustvo. 318 p. (In Bulgarian)

26. Kaliuzhnyi G.P. 2005. Ubiennye za bratoliubie [Killed for Brotherly Love]. In Vil'ers O.A., Popov V.A. Vospominaniia russkoi babushki. Piatigorskaia tragediia. Moscow: Entsiklopediia sel i dereven'. 336 p. (In Russian)

27. Kashirin V.B. 2011. Vysshii komandnyi sostav armii stran Balkanskogo poluostrova v otsenkakh i suzhdeniiakh russkikh voennykh spetsialistov v nachale XX veka [The Supreme Command of the Armies of the Countries of the Bal-kan Peninsula in the Estimates and Judgments of Russian Military Experts in the early 20th century]. Chelovek na Balkanakh glazami russkikh. Ed. by R.P. Grishina, A.L. Shemiakin. Saint Petersburg: Aleteiia. 344 p. P. 189-234. (In Russian)

28. Kashirin V.B. 2010. Pokhod v Dobrudzhanskuiu step': evoliutsiia zamysla, plani-rovanie i podgotovka ekspeditsii za Dunai v 1916 godu [The Campaign in the Dobrudja Steppe: the Evolution of Design, Planning and Preparation of the Expedition over the Danube in 1916]. STUDIA BALKANICA (K iubileiu R.P. Grishinoi). Ed. by A.L. Shemiakin. Moscow: ISl RAN. 400 p. P. 139-185. (In Russian)

29. Khristov P. 2017. Prest"pleniiata na general Radko Dimitriev [Crimes of General Radko Dimitriev]. Ed. by Ts. Biliarski. Sofia: Aniko. 281 p. (In Bulgarian)

30. Kosik V.I. 1991. Russkaia politika v Bolgarii. 1879–1886 [Russian Policy in Bulgaria. 1879–1886]. Moscow: B. i. 179 p. (In Russian)

31. Kravkov V.P. 2014. Velikaia voina bez retushi. Zapiski korpusnogo vracha [The Great War without Retouching. Notes of a Corps Doctor]. Moscow: Veche. 414 p. (In Russian)

32. Krasnyi terror v gody Grazhdanskoi voiny: po materialam Osoboi sledstvennoi komissii po rassledovaniiu zlodeianii bol'shevikov [The Red Terror during the Civil War: according to the Materials of the Special Commission of Inquiry to Investigate the Atrocities of the Bolsheviks]. 1992. Ed. by Fel'shtinskii Iu.G. London: Overseas Publications Interchange Ltd (OPI). 432 p. (In Russian)

33. Lopukhin V.B. 2008. Zapiski byvshego direktora departamenta Ministerstva inostran-nykh del [Notes of the Former Director of the Department of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs]. Saint Petersburg: Nestor-Istoriia. 536 p. (In Russian)

34. Mamontov N.P. 1913. S bolgarskimi voiskami ot Balkan do Chataldzhi [With Bulgarian Troops from the Balkans to Chatalja]. Moscow: Tip. t-va Mamontova. 175 p. (In Russian)

35. Markov G. 2012. B"lgariia v Balkanskiia s"iuz sreshchu Osmanskata imperiia 1911–1913 [Bulgaria in the Balkan Union against the Ottoman Empire 1911-1913]. Sofia: Zakharii Stoianov. 566 p. (In Bulgarian)

36. Miliukov P. 1917. Konstantinopol' i Prolivy [Constantinople and the Straits]. Vestnik Evropy. №2. P. 227-259. (In Russian)

37. Mitev T. 1981. Razreshavaneto na ofitsersko-emigrantskiia v"pros prez 90-te godini na XIX vek [Resolution of the Officer-Emigrant Question in the 90s of the 19th century]. Voennoistoricheski sbornik. №1. P. 38-49. (In Bulgarian)

38. Mikhailov A.A, Mikhailov V.V. 2017. Bolgarskie ofitsery – vypuskniki rossiiskoi Nikolaevskoi akademii General'nogo shtaba [Bulgarian Officers – Graduates of Russian Nikolaev Acad emy of the General Staff]. Slavianskii al'manakh. Vol. 3-4. P. 53-71. (In Russian) URL: https://inslav.ru/sites/default/files/editions/slav_alm_2017_3-4.pdf (accessed 23.09.2019)

39. Mikhov M. 1957. Novi danni za deinostta na general Radko Dimitriev v Ruskata armiia sled Fevruarskata revoliutsiia prez 1917 [New Data on the Activities of General Radko Dimitriev in the Russian Army after the February Revolution in 1917]. Voennoistoricheski sbornik. №1. P. 122-126. (In Bulgarian)

40. Novye voennye pesni. Geroi Radko Dmitriev [New War Songs. Hero Radko Dmitriev]. 1914. Moscow: A.S. Balashov. 16 p. (In Russian)

41. Os'kin M.V. 2007. Shturm Karpat. Zima 1915 goda [Storm Of The Carpathians. Winter of 1915]. Moscow: Tseikhgauz. 48 p. (In Russian)

42. Petrov L. 1991. General-leitenant Radko Dimitriev [Lieutenant General Radko Dimitriev]. Armeiski pregled. №12. P. 17-20. (In Bulgarian)

43. Pilenko A.A. 1913. Okolo Bolgarskoi voiny. Dnevnik i sorok deviat' liubitel'skikh fotografii [Near the Bulgarian War. Diary and Forty-Nine Photos]. Saint Pe-tersburg: Vechernee vremia. 218 p. (In Russian)

44. Polivanov A.A. 1924. Iz dnevnikov i vospominanii po dolzhnosti voennogo ministra i ego pomoshchnika. 1907–1916 [From Diaries and Memoirs on a Position of the Minister of War and His Assistant. 1907–1916]. Moscow: Vysshii voennyi redaktsionnyi sovet. 240 p. (In Russian)

45. Popov V. 1956. General Radko Dimitriev – zabelezhitelen b"lgarski polkovodets. Biografichni belezhki [General Radko Dimitriev is a Wonderful Bulgarian Colonel. Biographical Notes]. Voennoistoricheski sbornik. №2. P. 82-106. (In Bulgarian)

46. Potrashkov S.V. 2015. General Radko Dimitriev vo glave 3-i armii Iugo-Zapadnogo fronta [General Radko Dimitriev at the Head of the 3rd Army of the South-Western Front]. Drinovski sbornik (Drinovs'kii zbirnik). Vol. VIII. Kharkiv – Sofiia. P. 287–293. (In Russian)

47. Potrashkov S.V. 2007. General Radko Dimitriev na frontakh Pervoi mirovoi voiny (1914-1917) [General Radko Dimitriev on the Fronts of the First World War (1914-1917)]. Drinovski sbornik (Drinovs'kii zbirnik). Vol. I. Kharkiv – Sofiia. P. 180-193. (In Russian)

48. Potrashkov S.V. 2017. Fevral'skaia revoliutsiia 1917 g. i sud'ba generala Radko Dimitrieva [February Revolution of 1917 and the Fate of General Radko Dimitriev]. Drinovski sbornik (Drinovs'kii zbirnik). Vol. X. Kharkiv – Sofiia. P. 320-326. (In Russian)

49. Ratiev A.L. 1999. To, chto sokhranila mne pamiat' [What Memory Left Me]. Sofia,Izd-vo Sofia, Un-t im. Sv. Klimenta Okhridskogо. 681 p. (In Russian)

50. Rodzianko M.V. 1929. Krushenie imperii [The Collapse of the Empire]. Leningrad, Priboi. 271 p. (In Russian)

51. Shkundin G. 2009. Ne zamochit' li nam Koburga? Bolgariia v rossiiskoi voennoi strategii i politike vesnoi 1916 goda [Could We Kill Coburg? Bulgaria in the Russian Military Strategy and Policy in the Spring of 1916]. Rodina. №6. P. 54-59. (In Russian)

52. Shkuro A.G. 2004. Grazhdanskaia voina v Rossii: Zapiski belogo partizana [The Civil War in Russia: Notes of a White Partisan]. Moscow: ACT, Tranzitkniga. 540 p. (In Russian)

53. Shul'gin V.V. 2002. Poslednii ochevidets: Memuary. Ocherki. Sny [The Last Witness: the Memoirs. Essays. Sleeps]. Ed. by N.N. Lisovoi. Moscow: OLMA-PRESS, Zvezdnyi mir. 588 p. (In Russian)

54. Sovremennyi Skobelev doblestnyi geroi Radko Dimitriev i ego geroiskie podvigi v bitve s nemtsami [Modern Skobelev Valiant Hero Radko Dimitriev and his Heroic Deeds in the Battle with the Germans]. 1914. Moscow: Tipografiia P.V. Bel'tsova. 16 p. (In Russian)

55. Sr"bskite intrigi i kovarstva sreshchu B"lgariia (1804–1914) [Serbian Intrigues and Insidiousness against Bulgaria (1804-1914)]. 2009. Ed. by Ts.V. Biliarski. So-fia: Aniko. 659 p. (In Bulgarian)

56. Todorov K. 1994. Izpovedta na edna luda balkanska glava [Confessions of a Crazy Balkan Head]. Sofia: Letopisi. 505 p. (In Bulgarian)

57. Tsachevski V. 2018. Radko Dimitriev. P"lkovodets"t [Radko Dimitriev. General]. Sofia: Studia Transmedi. 430 p. (In Bulgarian)

58. Ududov A. 1976. General Radko Dimitriev v raiona na Riga prez 1916 g. [General Radko Dimitriev in the Riga Region in 1916]. Izvestiia na Instituta za voenna istoriia. Vol. 21. P. 139-141. (In Bulgarian)

59. Uzunov Khr. 1995. General Radko Dimitriev – voenen strategi i p"lkovodets [General Radko Dimitriev – Military Strategist and Commander]. Izvestiia na Instituta za voenna istoriia. Vol. 58. P. 236-251. (In Bulgarian)

60. Uzunov Khr. 1980. General-leitenant Radko Dimitriev [Lieutenant-General Radko Dimitriev]. Voennoistoricheski sbornik. №3. P. 181-188. (In Bulgarian)


Review

For citations:


Gusev N.S. The Fate of General Radko Dimitriev and His Memory in Context of Russian-Bulgarian Relations of the Late 19th – Early 20th centuries. MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2019;12(6):7-27. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2019-6-69-7-27

Views: 1452


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 2071-8160 (Print)
ISSN 2541-9099 (Online)