Is There Any Future for Coal Power Plants in Europe?
A. V. Zimakov – PhD (Economics), research fellow Center for European Studies, Primakov Institute of World Economy and International Relations, Russian Academy of Sciences. Address: 23, Profsoyuznaya Str., Moscow, 117997, Russian Federation. E-mail: Zimakov@newmail.ru
The article deals with the policies of EU countries towards coal power plants as well as practical steps taken by their governments. Coal power plants are widely considered to be environmentally harmful which confronts with environmental policies of the EU suggesting Europe-wide cuts of greenhouse gas emissions. Based on that assumption a number of EU countries such as Belgium, Austria, Portugal, Dania, Finland, Sweden and UK are striving to phase out coal power plants and achieved significant progress on this path replacing coal with other generation sources. On the other hand, other EU members are lagging behind as coal phase-out is not an urgent item of their political agenda. This situation is typical for Ireland, Netherlands, Italy, Croatia, Slovenia and Slovakia. Domestic coal extracting industry can pose a significant hindering factor for a coal power plants phase-out and can effectively block the process. This is the case in Bulgaria, Romania, Hungary, Czech Republic, Greece and Poland. But Germany, which also has a well-developed coal industry, transforms its energy sector towards a green one cutting the share of coal in the generation mix. If this effort of the German government proves successful it will deliver a positive transformation model for other EU countries with a large share of coal in generation-mix due to domestic coal extraction industry. The analysis of the political and economic (both macro and micro) processes leads to conclusion that there is no unity among EU member states in their approach towards coal fired power plants phase-out. This will allow for coal power plants to retain their market share in a short to medium term. But in the longer run one can expect a significant decrease of coal fired generation in Europe, even in the countries traditionally dependent on coal.
Keywords: EU energy market, nuclear energy, coal phase-out, coal industry, coal power station, EU environmental policy, green energy, renewables.
1. Dyomin V.F., Krylov D.A. Sravnenie riskov ot AES I TES dlia biosfery [Comparation of risks for biosphere of nuclear and coal power stations]. Energiia: ekonomika, tehnika, ekologiia. 2012, no. 1, pp. 28–36 (In Russian).
2. Zimakov A.V. Resheniie ob uskorennom vyhode Germanii iz atomnoi energetiki: Federalnyi administrativnyi sud, Konstitutsionnyi sud, mezhdunarodnyi arbitrazh. Chto dalshe? [The decision of an accelerated nuclear phase-out in Germany: Federal administrative court, Constitution cort, international arbitration. What comes next?] Mezhdunarodnoe ekonomicheskoe pravo. 2017, no. 2, pp. 42–56 (In Russian).
3. Kaveshnikov N. Yu. Strategia ES v oblasti klimata I energetiki.[EU strategy on climate and energy] Sovremennaia Evropa. 2015, no. 1 (61), pp. 93–103 (In Russian).
4. Kaveshnikov N. Yu. Vozobnovliaemaia energetika v ES: smena prioritetov.[Renewables energy in EU: change of priorities] Mirovaia ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnoshenia. 2014, no. 12, pp. 70–81 (In Russian).
5. Bernasconi-Osterwalder N., Brauch M. The State of Play in Vattenfall v. Germany II: Leaving the German public in the dark. The International Institute for Sustainable Development Briefing Note. Winnipeg, 2014, 8 p.
6. A stress test for coal in Europe under the Paris Agreement. Climate Analytics. Berlin, 2017. 62 p.
7. El carbón en España en 2016. El Observatorio Crítico de la Energía, 2016. 19 p. (In Spanish)
8. Elf Eckpunkte für einen Kohlekonsens. Konzept zur schrittweisen Dekarbonisierung des deutschen Stromsektors. Agora Energiewende. Berlin, 2016. 108 S. (In German).
9. Harris M., Beck M., Gerasimchuk I. The End of Coal: Ontario’s coal phase-out. Winnipeg: International Institute for Sustainable Development, 2015. 32 p.
10. Jones D., Gutmann K. End of an Era: Why every European country needs a coal phase-out plan. Greenpeace, 2015. Available at: https://www.greenpeace.de/sites/www.greenpeace.de/files/publications/end-of-eracoal-phase-out-plan-20151204.pdf.
11. Jirusek M., Vlcek T. Key factors that drive the Czech Republic coal industry. Coal International, May–June 2015, pp. 28–36.
12. Littlecott C. UK Coal Phase Out: The International Context. E3G Briefing Paper, November 2016. 9 p.
13. Littlecott C. The Coal Phase Out Transition: Italy’s Leadership Opportunity. E3G Briefing Paper, April 2017. 8 p.