From High Aspirations to Harsh Reality: EU Human Rights Promotion at The UN Human Rights Council

Anatoly S. Boyashov – PhD student at the Saint Petersburg State University, Universitetskaya nab., 7/9, 199034, Russia, and at Bielefeld University, Universitätsstraße, 25, 33501, Germany. E-mail: a.boyashov@spbu.ru.
 
Archive: 
Вся статья: 

DOI 10.24833/2071-8160-2017-6-57-174-195 (Read the article in PDF)

Since 1990s the EU has been highly aspirational on its role in human rights promotion on a global scale, which has led to the EU’s proactive participation in international organizations. The Union identifies itself as ‘global human rights force’ but less and less acts in accordance with that identity at the UN HRC. At this intergovernmental body the EU acts as a smoothly coordinated block, which is contested by the other regional and political coalitions of states. The emerged multi-polar world system urges for a less normative analysis of EU human rights promotion.

The article proposes and applies 4 measurable indicators to assess the EU actorness in human rights promotion: 1) explicitness of references to the UN or global fora in the EU primary law and secondary legislation related to human rights promotion; 2) degree of support/contestation for the EU objectives by other non-EU actors at the HRC; 3) degree of (in)cohesiveness of EU external representation at the HRC; 4) EU (in)consistency in formulating priorities and using instruments at the HRC.

Multi-polar world system questions the EU high aspirations as ‘a global force’ in human rights promotion. The EU ability to use its instruments in human rights promotion is moderate even despite its enhanced burden sharing among the EU member states, a hybrid system of representation, a vast diplomatic and NGOs’ network. ‘Big’ states still play the leading role in this process. The internal disagreement among the EU member states weakens the EU human rights promotion. The UN HRC structural context limits the EU opportunity to promote human rights, therefore, the EU tries to be less loud and less visible.

Key words: the European Union, Human Rights, the United Nations, the Human Rights Council, multi-polar world system.

References
1.    Ajevski M. Fragmentation in International Human Rights Law — Beyond Conflict of Laws. Nordic Journal of Human Rights, 2014, vol. 32, no. 2, pp. 87-98.
2.    Bretherton Ch., Vogler J. The European Union as a Global Actor. London: Routledge. 2006. 288 p.
3.    Chané A., Sharma A. Universal Human Rights? Exploring Contestation and Consensus in the UN Human Rights Council. Human Rights & International Legal Discourse, 2016, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 219-247.
4.    Gstöhl S.’Patchwork Power’ Europe: The EU's Representation in International Institutions. European Foreign Affairs Review, 2009, vol. 14, no. 3, pp. 385-403.
5.    Haasz V. Jaraczewski J. Podstawa K. Human Rights Policy Toolbox. Factsheet No 1. Diplomatic Tools. European Commission. FRAME Project. 2017. 77 p. [Электронный ресурс] URL: http://www.fp7-frame.eu/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Deliverable-14.3.pdf (accessed 22.10.2017).
6.    Human Rights Watch. 2017. The Costs of International Advocacy. China’s Interference in United Nations Human Rights Mechanisms. HRW, printed in U.S.A. 123 p. [Электронный ресурс] URL: https://www.hrw.org/sites/default/files/report_pdf/chinaun0917_web.pdf (accessed 22.10.2017).
7.    Jørgensen K. A Multilateralist Role for the EU. The European Union's Roles in International Politics: Concepts and Analysis. Ed. by Elgstrøm O., Smith M. London, Frank Cass Publ., 2006. Pp. 30-46.
8.    Kutejnikov A. Vektory izmenenij i sovremennoe sostojanie OON. K 70-letiju Ob"edinennyj Nacij [Pathways of Change and the Current UN Status]. Mezhdunarodnye protsessy, 2015, vol. 13, no. 4 (43), pp. 20-44.
9.    Laatikainen K., Smith K. Introduction: The Multilateral Politics of UN Diplomacy. The Hague Journal of Diplomacy, 2017, vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 1-18.
10.    Niemann A., Bretherton Ch. EU External Policy at the Crossroads: The Challenge of Actorness and Effectiveness. International Relations, 2013, vol. 27, no. 3, pp. 261-275.
11.    Schmidt M. The Position of the European Union in the United Nations: a United Nations Perspective. The European Union in International Organisations and Global Governance. Ed. by Kaddous Ch. Oxford, Hart Publ., 2015. Pp. 35-44.
12.    Smith K. The European Union at the Human Rights Council: speaking with one voice but having little influence. Journal of European Public Policy, 2010, vol. 17, no. 2, pp. 224-241.
13.    Smith K. The European Union and the Politics of Legitimisation at the United Nations. European Foreign Affairs Review, 2013, vol. 18, no. 1, pp. 63-80.
14.    Smith K. The EU as a diplomatic actor in the field of human rights. The European Union as a Diplomatic Actor. The European Union in international affairs. Ed. by Koops J. Macaj Gj. London, Palgrave Macmillan Publ., 2014. Pp. 155-177.
15.    Smith K. EU Member States at the UN: A Case of Europeanization arrested? Journal of Common Market Studies, 2017, vol. 55, no. 3, pp. 628-644.
16.    Trunov F. FRG kak centr vlijanija v mnogopoljarnom mire: Osobennosti podhoda k ispol'zovaniju sily [Germany as a center of influence in multi-polar world: particularities of the approach to the use of force]. Aktual'nye problemy Evropy, 2017, no. 1, pp. 185-206.
17.    Tuominen H. The Role of the European Union at the United Nations Human Rights Council. Academic Dissertation, Helsinki, Unigrafia, 2016. 202 p. [Электронный ресурс] URL: http://urn.fi/URN:ISBN:978-951-51-2184-4 (accessed 22.10.2017).
18.    Wouters J. Chané A. Brussels Meets Westphalia: The European Union and the United Nations. The European Union’s External Action in Times of Crisis. Ed. by Eeckhout P., Lopez-Escudero M. Oxford, Hart Publ., 2016. Pp. 299-323.
19.    Wouters J., Chané A., Ramopoulos Th. Improving the European Union’s Status in the United Nations and the UN System: An Objective Without a Strategy?”. Ed. by Ch. Kaddous. The European Union in International Organisations and Global Governance. Oxford, Hart Publ., 2015. Pp. 45-74.
20.    Wouters J., Meuwissen K. The European Union at the UN Human Rights Council: Multilateral Human Rights Protection Coming of Age? European Journal of Human Rights, 2014, no. 2, pp. 135-172.
21.    Zaru D. Geurts Ch. Legal Framework of EU Participation in Global Human Rights Governance”. The European Union and Multilateral Governance. Ed. by J. Wouters, H. Bruyninckx, S. Basu, S. Schunz. Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan Publ., 2012. Pp. 49-65.